The Case of the Vanishing Violin

Seventeen-year-old Emma follows mortar-stained footprints toward a stolen violin—and someone listening inside the walls.

The Case of the Vanishing Violin

The Silence at Lockwood

Emma Carter had one foot inside Lockwood Manor when Professor Grey accused her of stealing his violin.

“Turn out your pockets.”

She produced a pencil, two peppermint wrappers, and a notebook with a loose cover. The professor examined them beneath the porch lamp.

“Disappointing,” he said.

“For both of us. I came to find your Stradivarius.”

Behind him, something ticked with the stubborn rhythm of a dripping tap. Emma peered past his shoulder at a pendulum swinging between two brass plates.

“An experiment?”

“It measures vibration.”

“Then perhaps don’t lean against it.”

He straightened. The ticking stopped.

For three November evenings, no music had travelled from the manor above Greystone. In the baker’s queue, people discussed burglars, insurance fraud, and a violin that had finally tired of Yorkshire. Emma preferred explanations with evidence. At seventeen, she also wanted a case more substantial than Mrs Dobson’s missing washing.

“The constable thinks I’ve misplaced it,” Grey said, admitting her. “As though it were a teaspoon.”

His study smelled of hot dust and furniture wax. Tuning forks stood in wooden racks beside an empty violin case. Grey touched the hollow where the instrument belonged, then pulled his hand away.

“Thursday night. I played until ten. Locked the case. Found it empty at breakfast.”

“Who has access?”

“My groundskeeper, Amos. He brings firewood. Nobody else.”

“And the key?”

“On the mantel.”

Emma looked at him.

“I see your point,” he said.

A pale smear crossed the hearthrug. Beneath the window, the dust held the print of a heavy boot: broad heel, one triangular piece missing.

She followed three more prints into the corridor. They ended at a tapestry of cavalry charging across a field.

“Have you searched behind that?”

“It’s a wall.”

Emma lifted the woollen corner. Cold air brushed her wrist. A narrow door stood ajar behind it, its edge bright with fresh scratches.

Grey fetched a lantern without another word.

The Explorer’s Box

The passage scraped Emma’s shoulders and smelled of plaster. Ahead, a thread of light slipped through a crack; somewhere beyond it, iron struck stone.

Grey caught her sleeve.

“Mice?” he whispered.

“Very industrious ones.”

The sound stopped.

They emerged into a circular room with a domed ceiling. On a pedestal stood a velvet-lined box, long enough for a violin.

Emma opened it.

Grey let out a breath that seemed to take the warmth from the room.

Inside lay a journal, its leather curled like an overbaked crust. On the velvet beside it was a clean rectangle where something had recently rested.

“Someone opened this before us,” Emma said.

Grey recognised the handwriting. “My great-grandfather. He travelled. Brought home more objects than explanations.”

The pages listed ports, purchases, storms. Between an account of a broken carriage axle and the price of oranges, Emma found the Stradivarius.

Paid Matteo Bellandi for his violin. He wept to part with it. Promised him it would not spend its life behind glass.

“Did your great-grandfather play?” she asked.

“Badly, according to my grandmother.”

A later entry had been underlined.

The lower strongroom is finished. Its key shall sleep among the sonnets, where my wife says no thief will trouble to look.

Emma examined the box again. Pale grit clung to its hinge, the same colour as the boot marks.

“Who has been working below the house?”

“Amos repaired the cellar steps last week. Lime mortar.”

“We should speak to him.”

“He’s visiting his sister until Monday.”

From inside the wall came a soft metallic scrape.

Emma lowered the lid carefully.

“Perhaps she lives closer than you think.”


In the library, Grey dragged over a ladder. Emma searched the lower shelves while he read out titles above her.

“Sermons. More sermons. A remarkable quantity of sermons.”

“Sonnets,” she reminded him.

“I’m attempting optimism.”

She found the book beneath a loose shelf: small, calf-bound, its spine newly rubbed clean. Inside, the pages had been cut around a brass key.

Emma lifted it by its ribbon.

“He put it back,” she said.

Grey stared towards the door. “He still needs it.”

The Room Beneath the House

Emma wanted the constable. Grey wanted the violin before anyone carried it out through another forgotten door.

They compromised badly: they went downstairs.

At the cellar’s far end stood a stone door carved with vines. Fresh mortar dust whitened the floor. Emma fitted the brass key into its lock.

“Leave that here,” she whispered when Grey raised the lantern. “Someone will see us coming.”

She set it behind a coal bin. Light spilled low across the steps.

The lock turned reluctantly.

Beyond the door, a candle illuminated a marble plinth. The Stradivarius lay on a folded blanket, its varnish glowing amber. Beside it stood a padded travelling case.

Grey moved forward.

“Don’t touch it,” Amos said.

The groundskeeper stepped from behind the plinth with a short iron bar. Mortar streaked his trousers. On his right boot, a triangular piece was missing from the heel.

“I hoped you’d stay upstairs, Professor.”

“You took it.” Grey’s voice cracked on the final word.

“My father tended this place. His father before him. I patch your roofs, mend your drains, and you ask whether I’ve wiped my boots.”

“So you steal a violin?”

Amos lifted the bar. “I take what this family owes mine.”

Emma glanced at the travelling case. There was a railway timetable beneath its handle.

“You weren’t keeping it as an inheritance,” she said.

“Mind your business.”

“You found the journal while fixing the steps. But without that case, you couldn’t safely carry it away.”

His eyes flicked towards the door. Emma stepped aside, leaving him a clear path.

“All right,” she said. “We’ll go.”

She retreated to the threshold. Grey remained beside the plinth.

“Professor.”

Amos reached for the violin.

Grey snatched it first.

The iron bar struck marble with a crack. Emma grabbed Grey’s coat and hauled him through the doorway. Amos lunged after them, slipping on the blanket dragged beneath his boot.

They shoved the stone door together. The key turned just as his shoulder hit the other side.

For a moment, nobody spoke.

Then Grey whispered, “Did he strike it?”

Emma looked at the instrument clutched beneath his chin.

“Play something.”

What the Walls Kept

“I haven’t a bow,” Grey said.

“Then pluck it.”

He touched one string. A clear note trembled through the cellar.

Behind the door, Amos swore.

Emma sat abruptly on the bottom step. Her knees had begun shaking now that there was nothing useful for them to do.

“That,” she said, “is a very expensive way to check for damage.”

Grey lowered himself beside her, still holding the violin.

“You wanted the constable.”

“I intend to mention that quite often.”


The constable arrived with two men and a pair of handcuffs. While Amos battered the stone from inside, they examined the upper passage and discovered a listening slit behind the circular chamber.

Through it, Amos had heard them reading the journal. When they went to the library, he had hurried downstairs to pack the violin.

“Why leave the key in the book?” the constable asked.

“Because a missing key would make the professor search,” Emma said. “He meant to put everything back as he found it.”

“Except my violin,” Grey said.

Amos came out rubbing his shoulder. He said nothing when the constable opened the travelling case and found a dealer’s letter offering cash, with no questions about ownership.

At the front door, Grey stopped him.

“If I owed your family wages, you could have brought me the accounts.”

Amos looked away. “You’d have sent me to your solicitor.”

Grey’s hand tightened on the banister. He did not deny it.


On Monday, a parcel arrived at Emma’s house: a stout new notebook and an invitation to Lockwood Manor.

She found Grey in the study, placing two chairs beside the music stand.

“No more locked case?” she asked.

“A better lock. And a less obvious place for the key.”

He handed her the violin.

Emma kept both hands behind her back. “I don’t play.”

“Neither did my great-grandfather, properly. Bellandi was still owed something.”

“Lessons?”

“If you’ll tolerate them.”

Her first note made them both wince. Down in Greystone, the baker opened his upstairs window, listened, and shut it again.

For the first time in years, laughter followed the music out of Lockwood Manor.

The End
The Enigma of Ludlow Manor Read next The Enigma of Ludlow Manor A detective follows knocking through an abandoned manor, where a priest recognizes more than he admits. 6 min read →