The Clock-Struck Murders

Two murders share a stopped clock, and a constable suspects someone is manufacturing the town’s past.

The Clock-Struck Murders

The Hand That Moved

Constable Charles Trenton was kneeling beside Marcus Doyle’s body when the clock above the dead carpenter struck four—with its hands fixed at 3:13.

The bell rattled through the workshop. Outside, someone dropped a milk bottle.

Charles stood without touching the bench. Marcus lay beneath his mortising machine, one cheek pressed into curls of pale oak. Blood had soaked the sawdust under his collar, but the machine’s cutting head was clean.

“Belt caught him,” said the doctor from the doorway.

“With the power disconnected?”

The plug lay on the floor. Charles crouched again. Beneath Marcus’s ear was a narrow wound, deep enough to admit a carpenter’s marking awl.

Across the street, shutters began opening along Merrow’s cobbled square.

“Keep them back,” Charles told his assistant. “And find whoever last worked on that clock.”

Its walnut case was newly polished. A crescent of clean plaster showed beside it, as though another clock had recently hung there.

Marcus’s sister arrived carrying the lunch he would never eat. She set it carefully on the bench.

“He hated that thing,” she said.

“The clock?”

“Bought it at the heritage sale last month. Said Jonathan Clarke could sell frost to a butcher.” Her fingers tightened around the lunch cloth. “Are you going to cover him?”

Charles took off his coat.


For nineteen days, he found nothing strong enough to put before a magistrate.

Jonathan had sold six clocks to raise money for Merrow’s preservation society. Marcus had bought one; the school librarian, Wilhelmina Clark, another. Nobody remembered the remaining buyers.

Then Wilhelmina was found in her attic, folded over a chest of old books.

A clock hung above her.

Three thirteen.

Charles reached her house before the doctor. Her grandson Jonathan stood at the foot of the stairs, gripping the banister so hard his knuckles shone.

“She was eighty-one,” Jonathan said. “Perhaps her heart—”

Charles saw the thin red puncture beneath her ear.

“No,” he said. “Not her heart.”

What the Town Remembered

By morning, three families had carried their clocks into the square and smashed them with a coal hammer.

Charles stepped around the broken faces on his way to Eliza Moore’s house. She answered holding a bread knife.

“For the loaf,” she said, following his glance. “Although the newspaper man was here.”

Her sitting room smelled of toast, furniture wax and the coal dust that settled on everything in Merrow. Charles refused tea. Eliza poured it anyway.

“Tell me about the Doyles and the Clarks.”

She stopped with the pot tilted.

“Who’s been telling you that rubbish?”

“Half the town.”

The story was everywhere now: two founding families, a quarrel over land, a dawn duel that killed both patriarchs. Their household clocks had supposedly stopped together at 3:13.

“My grandmother heard it from hers,” Eliza said. “That makes it old, not true.”

She fetched a parish register, bracing its cracked spine against her wrist. Two men who allegedly killed each other appeared together as witnesses at a wedding eleven years afterward.

Charles bent over the signatures.

“Wilhelmina found those last winter,” Eliza said. “She was preparing a proper history. Jonathan wanted the duel for his heritage exhibition. Said visitors needed something dramatic.”

“Did they quarrel?”

“She told him history wasn’t a puppet he could make dance.”

Charles set down his untouched cup.

“And Marcus?”

“He was repairing the exhibition cases. Until he fell out with Jonathan over unpaid wages.”

Eliza opened a drawer and handed Charles a printed leaflet.

MERROW MUST REMEMBER.
The old families paid in blood. Shall we sell their inheritance for a shopping arcade?

Below the words stood a drawing of a clock: 3:13.

“Jonathan printed that before either death?”

“In August.”

Charles folded it into his pocket.

At the door, Eliza caught his sleeve.

“Wilhelmina was researching the proposed building site, too. She told me she’d found something useful.”

“Useful to whom?”

“To anyone willing to read it. That was generally her difficulty with Jonathan.”

The Room Behind the Map

At the council meeting that evening, Jonathan Clarke seized the mayor’s plans and tore them across the middle.

“Two dead!” he shouted. “How many more before you understand what you’re destroying?”

Charles watched from beside the stove.

The mayor gathered the pieces. “Your grandmother supported negotiations.”

“She was deceived.”

“She asked for a public reading of the original deed.”

Jonathan’s chair scraped backward.

Charles followed him into the passage.

“You repaired your grandmother’s clock last Tuesday.”

“I wound it.”

“You told my assistant you hadn’t visited her for a fortnight.”

Jonathan looked toward the outer door. “I’ve hardly slept. You expect me to remember every—”

“Yes.”


The warrant took until morning.

Jonathan’s house contained three clocks, all running, and a fourth lying dismantled beneath his bed. Behind a wall map of old Merrow, Charles found a shallow door fastened with a brass hook.

The room beyond had once been a cupboard. Now its shelves held clock movements, exhibition leaflets and plans of the proposed arcade.

“Society property,” Jonathan said from the doorway.

Charles lifted a walnut clock case. Its pendulum compartment held a marking awl wrapped in a handkerchief. Dark material crusted the shaft.

Jonathan’s mouth opened, then closed.

In a drawer lay two brass minute hands. Both had been bent at the socket. Charles had already found their replacements on the murder clocks, fixed to the hour hands with solder.

“You made them stay at thirteen minutes past,” he said. “But left the striking mechanisms working.”

“That proves I repaired them.”

“There’s a missing screw from Marcus’s clock in this drawer. And his blood, I expect, on his own awl.”

Jonathan lunged for the case.

Charles caught his wrist against the doorframe. The clock struck the floor; springs burst across the boards with a metallic snarl.

“My grandmother was going to let them pull it all down,” Jonathan said into the wood.

Charles tightened the handcuff.

“Then you should have let her speak.”

The Reading

Jonathan confessed before noon.

Marcus had discovered him altering the clocks and threatened to tell the council that the heritage exhibition was built around a falsehood. Jonathan killed him in the workshop and arranged the body beneath the machine.

Then Wilhelmina found a solder burn on her grandson’s cuff.

“She knew what it meant,” he said. “She always noticed everything.”

Charles waited while the clerk’s pen scratched.

“She said we were going to your office together. She took my hand as though I were still six.” Jonathan rubbed the place where the handcuff had marked him. “I only wanted her to listen.”

“She couldn’t listen after you killed her.”

Jonathan pressed his lips together.

The second clock had been his answer to the first murder: another victim, another stopped face, a legend made large enough to hide a man inside.


Three days later, Charles attended the postponed council meeting. He carried Wilhelmina’s library folder, recovered from beneath the books in her attic chest.

“She wasn’t selling the site,” he told the mayor.

The original owners had given the land jointly for a school and public reading room. Wilhelmina’s research had traced a restriction missed in the modern conveyances. Commercial building would return ownership to the two families’ surviving descendants.

Marcus had agreed to enforce it with her. His signed instruction to a solicitor lay inside the folder.

Charles placed both documents on the table.

No one reached for them immediately.


Jonathan received a life sentence in the spring. By autumn, the arcade proposal had been withdrawn, and the old school reopened as Merrow’s library.

Eliza came to the opening with Wilhelmina’s repaired clock under her arm.

“Must we hang that?” the mayor asked.

“She paid good money for it,” Eliza said.

Charles fixed it above the lending desk. Beneath it stood the exhibition case Marcus had finished, containing the deed and the wedding register, open at the two signatures.

At thirteen minutes past three, Eliza looked up from her book.

The minute hand moved on.

The End
The Keeper of the Balance Read next The Keeper of the Balance Detective Blake unveils a murder plot in the foggy, secret-laden city of Greyford. 4 min read →