Wyatt Earp Takes Down Jesse James

A stolen mare leads Wyatt Earp to an undertaker—and a gunman's unsettling purchase.

Listen to this story · narrated, 10 minutes

Wyatt Earp Takes Down Jesse James

A Horse Without a Star

Wyatt Earp found Jesse James’s horse before he found Jesse James—and the horse was standing outside Deadwood’s undertaker.

Summer heat had softened the pitch between the boardwalk planks. Flies worried a split sack of oats beneath the hitching rail. The mare lowered her head as Wyatt approached, showing a rubbed patch beneath the saddle and a left ear notched like a torn envelope.

“That’s her,” Deputy Jack Mercer said.

Wyatt rubbed his thumb across the mare’s forehead. Black came away on his skin. Beneath the polish was a crooked white star.

Jack caught the rail.

“Ruth painted that star on every scrap of paper in the house after he took her.”

“Keep your voice down.”

For three months, Wyatt had followed robbed trains, emptied banks, and men who remembered nothing until somebody offered money. Jack had joined the chase after Jesse’s gang stole his daughter’s mare outside a church picnic.

The undertaker’s door opened. A narrow man carrying a brass-handled coffin stopped at the sight of them.

“Customer inside?” Wyatt asked.

“Ordered six coffins. Wanted a price for paying ahead.”

“What did you tell him?”

“I said I preferred to measure first.”

From inside came a laugh, followed by the scrape of a chair.

Wyatt moved his coat away from his revolver.

A rear door slammed.

By the time they reached the alley, a rider was disappearing between two freight sheds on a borrowed bay. Wyatt raised his gun, then lowered it. A woman carrying a sleeping child stepped into the lane.

Jack swore softly.

Inside the shop, the undertaker pointed to six dollar coins arranged on a coffin lid.

“Deposit,” he said.

Wyatt looked back at the mare.

“Take her to the livery. Feed her yourself.”

“You think he’ll come back for her?”

“No,” Wyatt said. “I think he came here for something worth more.”

The Road into Deadwood

The bank manager kept wiping his spectacles although they were already clean.

“Twenty-eight thousand dollars,” he said. “Mine payroll. Due on the morning coach.”

Wyatt stood beside the manager’s desk. Through the open window came the ring of horseshoes and a butcher shouting about fresh liver.

“Who knows?”

“The owners. The driver. My clerks.”

“And everyone your clerks drink with.”

The spectacles stopped moving.

“Can you protect it?”

“I can try to keep men from getting killed over it.”

By supper, Jack had gathered eight volunteers: miners, a teamster, two former soldiers, and a butcher whose shotgun smelled faintly of sausage grease. Wyatt checked their weapons behind the jail.

“Nobody fires at movement. Nobody fires at dust. You shoot when you see a man shooting at you.”

The butcher swallowed. “And if we see James?”

“Same rule.”

Jack waited until the others had gone.

“We could catch him at the bank.”

“With clerks behind him and children at the windows?”

Wyatt spread a freight map across the bench. North of town, the coach road narrowed between an abandoned ore shed and a bank of scrub oak. Beyond it stood an old horse corral with one broken side.

“Here. We stop him before he reaches anybody who didn’t volunteer.”

Jack studied the map, then took a folded drawing from his pocket. A small girl had drawn a white star on an enormous brown horse.

“Ruth asked whether her mare remembered her.”

“Does she whistle to it?”

“Two notes. Horse comes looking for bread.”

“Go tell her the mare’s at the livery.”

Jack folded the drawing along its worn creases.

“After tomorrow.”

Wyatt reached across and held the paper flat beneath his palm.

“Tonight, Jack. Don’t make a child wait on a gunfight.”

Six Riders at Daybreak

Morning smelled of hot sage before the sun had cleared the ridge.

Wyatt lay behind an overturned ore wagon, watching ants carry a dead beetle beneath its wheel. Across the road, Jack crouched beside the butcher. Nobody had spoken for twenty minutes.

Then came hoofbeats.

Six riders rounded the bend, loose in their saddles. Jesse rode the borrowed bay. He wore a pale linen coat, and his right hand rested on his thigh, close to his revolver.

Wyatt stood.

“Jesse James. Put your hands where I can see them.”

The bay checked hard. One of the riders reached for a rifle.

“Don’t,” Wyatt said.

Jesse smiled without showing his teeth.

“You brought quite a church choir, Earp.”

“They’re waiting on you.”

Jesse’s revolver cleared leather.

The first shot tore a splinter from the wagon beside Wyatt’s cheek. He dropped behind the wheel as the road erupted.

Crack. Crack. Rifle fire struck the ore shed. A horse screamed and bolted riderless toward town. The butcher’s shotgun boomed once; afterward he stared at it until Jack dragged him down by the collar.

Wyatt fired at a man aiming over his saddle. The man fell sideways, boot caught briefly in a stirrup.

“Drop them!” Wyatt shouted. “You’ve got no road out!”

Someone answered with a shot that punched through the wagon bed.

The teamster beside Wyatt folded over his own hands. Blood darkened his trousers above the knee.

Wyatt pulled him behind the axle, cinched a neckerchief around the wound, and shoved the man’s fingers against it.

“Hold there.”

“Don’t leave me.”

“I’m right here.”

Across the road, two outlaws threw down their guns. Another lay facedown in the dust.

But the borrowed bay stood empty beside the scrub.

Wyatt counted again.

Five men.

He looked toward the brush behind them.

The Man Behind the Brush

A twig broke behind Wyatt, too close to be across the road.

“Leave that fellow,” Jesse said.

Wyatt kept one hand pressed against the teamster’s wound. His revolver lay in the dust beside his knee.

Jesse stood ten paces away among the scrub oak. A bullet had cut his coat sleeve. His gun was steady.

“You could still surrender,” Wyatt said.

“To your butcher?”

“To me.”

Jesse glanced toward the road. Jack was disarming a prisoner, his back turned.

“Call him over.”

Wyatt didn’t move.

“Call him, or I shoot the man under your hand.”

The teamster’s fingers closed on Wyatt’s cuff.

Not Jack.

“You bought six coffins yesterday,” Wyatt said.

“Undertaker told you that?”

“There are six of you.”

Jesse’s mouth tightened.

Wyatt lifted his bloody hand from the bandage.

“All right. I’m standing up.”

He rose slowly, his boot beside the fallen revolver.

“Hands higher,” Jesse said.

Behind him, an injured horse stumbled through the brush. Jesse shifted half a step to keep it out of his way.

Wyatt dropped.

His fingers closed around the revolver as Jesse fired. Something struck Wyatt’s upper arm like a hammer swung through fire. His own shot came before his knee touched earth.

Jesse staggered against an oak trunk. He looked down at the hole in his coat, then tried to raise his gun again.

It slipped from his hand.

Jack reached them with his revolver drawn.

“Wyatt!”

“See to him.”

Jack knelt beside Jesse. After a moment, he removed his hat.

Wyatt sat down hard beside the teamster and pushed his good hand back onto the bandage.

“You’re bleeding too,” the man whispered.

“Then we’ll share the doctor.”

Jack came back, tore a strip from his shirt, and bound Wyatt’s arm. His hands shook so badly he had to start the knot twice.

The Rider Missing from the Parade

Deadwood celebrated before the blood had dried on Wyatt’s sleeve.

By noon, somebody had hung bunting outside the saloon. By evening, the story included twelve outlaws, two hidden rifles, and a knife fight that nobody present remembered.

The teamster survived. Three prisoners went into the jail. The payroll arrived beneath an escort whose members complained loudly about missing breakfast.

Jesse lay in the undertaker’s coolest room.

“One coffin,” the undertaker told Wyatt. “I’ll return the balance.”

“Give it to the teamster’s wife.”

The undertaker nodded and closed his ledger.


Two days later, Jack found Wyatt behind the livery, struggling to buckle a bridle one-handed.

“They’re waiting for you. Brass band and everything.”

Wyatt tightened the strap beneath the mare’s jaw.

“Sounds expensive.”

“Mayor borrowed a carriage.”

“He can ride in it.”

Jack reached for the reins, then stopped.

The black polish had been washed away. The mare’s white star shone crookedly between her eyes.

“Ruth knows she’s here,” Jack said. “She hasn’t gone near her.”

“Why not?”

“Says that’s Jesse James’s horse now.”

Wyatt glanced toward the distant braying of a cornet.

“Well. Let’s ask the horse.”

They found Ruth on her porch, picking the crust from a piece of bread. She tucked her bare feet beneath her when Wyatt stopped at the gate.

“Deputy,” Wyatt said solemnly, “we need a witness.”

Jack leaned against the gatepost.

Ruth looked from her father to the mare.

“Go ahead,” he said.

Two small, uncertain notes came through the gap in her teeth.

The mare pulled the reins straight out of Wyatt’s good hand.

Ruth sprang off the porch. Bread disappeared into a velvet muzzle, and the girl wrapped both arms around the horse’s neck.

Downtown, the band struck up again.

Wyatt stayed to mend the gate latch the mare had broken.

The End
The Hawk and the Snake: A Tale of Valor in Coyote Creek Read next The Hawk and the Snake: A Tale of Valor in Coyote Creek John 'Hawk-Eye' Hawkins challenges outlaw Snake-Eyes Sullivan, bringing peace and courage to Coyote Creek. 3 min read →