Legends and Redemption in Dusty Hollow

A gambler buys a quiet room, but a pursuing marshal brings his unfinished reckoning to town.

Line Shape Image
Line Shape Image
Legends and Redemption in Dusty Hollow

A Room Without Questions

Jeremiah Blake won the deed to a stranger’s mule before Maggie Mae noticed he had been playing with an unloaded revolver.

“Either you’re remarkably brave,” she said, setting whiskey beside him, “or that fellow owes you money already.”

“I dislike making widows over cards.”

“Then don’t play husbands.”

He smiled and slid the deed back across the table. The loser gathered it with shaking fingers. Outside, the afternoon heat had softened the pitch between the boards of Dusty Hollow’s hitching rail; Jeremiah’s dappled mare stood switching flies beside it.

He wanted a room, three quiet nights, and enough winnings to reach the California line. Maggie wanted payment in advance.

He put down two silver dollars.

“That buys the bed,” she said. “Questions cost extra.”

“I’ll take only the bed.”

By supper, people had supplied their own answers. Jeremiah had killed six men in Abilene. He had married a senator’s daughter. He could shoot a cigar from a moving man’s teeth.

“Did the man ask him to?” Maggie inquired.

Nobody knew.

She watched Jeremiah through the steam rising from her dishpan. He gave the youngest freight hand his chair, drank his whiskey slowly, and never sat with his back to the door.

Later, she found him on the rear steps, rubbing the mare’s sweat-stiffened bridle with tallow.

“You planning to stay?”

“Depends who asks.”

“The proprietor. West wall needs painting.”

“I’m a poor painter.”

“It’s a poor wall.”

He looked at her then, properly. Flour dust whitened one sleeve; a small burn marked her wrist.

“You offer every stranger work?”

“Only the ones who return mules they’ve honestly stolen.”

His thumb stopped moving over the leather.

“I didn’t say honestly.”

“Neither did your face.”

From the street came the clop of another horse, traveling hard. Jeremiah stood before its rider reached the window.

The Woman at the Door

Clara Weston entered with white alkali crusted around her boot soles and a marshal’s star pinned to her coat. She shut the door carefully behind her.

“Jeremiah Blake.”

He placed his whiskey on the bar.

“Marshal.”

“Hands where I can see them.”

The room quieted. Someone lowered a fork onto a plate without letting it ring.

Jeremiah spread his hands. “Been a long ride?”

“Longer than yours. You change horses more often.”

Maggie moved out from behind the bar. “What’s he wanted for?”

“The federal payroll robbery at Copper Cut. Three years ago.”

“I heard nobody died there,” said a freight hand.

Clara kept her eyes on Jeremiah. “The guard lived eleven days.”

Jeremiah looked down at his open hands.

“I didn’t shoot him.”

“You held the horses.”

“Yes.”

That small word spoiled every grand story the room had made about him.

Maggie folded her arms. “And you let folks here call you a gentleman.”

“Folks rarely ask permission.”

“Don’t charm me now.”

He closed his mouth.

Clara drew a pair of irons from her coat. “The man who fired was Amos Voss. I need you alive to say so before a judge.”

Jeremiah’s gaze shifted toward the window.

“You came alone?”

“My deputy broke his leg outside Prescott.”

“Anybody follow you?”

“Why?”

Before he answered, Maggie heard a horse snort in the alley. Then a second.

Jeremiah stepped away from the bar.

“How much cash is in town?”

“None of your business,” Maggie said.

“Freight company paying tomorrow?”

Her eyes flicked toward the locked storeroom.

“Damn you,” she whispered.

“Not me.” He looked at Clara. “Voss always did like collecting two debts on one ride.”

The front window burst inward.

Clara struck Maggie below the shoulder and drove her down behind a table as glass peppered the floor.

The Price of Staying

A bottle split above Jeremiah’s head, spilling rye down his collar. He crawled behind the bar and reached for his revolver.

Empty.

Maggie stared at it. “You brought that thing to a gunfight?”

“I was hoping for cards.”

Clara fired through the broken window. A horse screamed outside, followed by a man swearing.

“Five riders,” she said. “One at the back.”

A voice carried from the street.

“Send Blake out, Marshal. Leave the freight money on the steps. We’ll trouble nobody else.”

Jeremiah shut his eyes briefly.

“Amos,” he called, “you still making promises wholesale?”

A bullet punched through the bar. Maggie flinched as an oak splinter cut her cheek.

Clara pushed a cartridge box across the floor.

“Load. Slowly. Let me see.”

Jeremiah obeyed. His fingertips slipped once against the brass.

“The alley runs behind the laundry,” Maggie said. “You knew that already, didn’t you?”

He glanced at her.

“You’ve been measuring exits since you arrived.”

The rear latch lifted.

Jeremiah fired through the lower door panel. A boot scraped the steps; someone fell heavily against the water barrel.

“That exit’s occupied,” he said.

“I meant you could leave.”

“I know.”

For a moment, all they heard was glass settling and a frightened man praying beneath the billiard table.

Then Voss shouted, “Last offer!”

Clara turned toward the sound. A shot struck her upper arm, spinning her against the bar. Her rifle hit the floor.

Jeremiah caught her before her head struck the brass rail.

“Stay with us, Marshal.”

“Wasn’t planning otherwise.” She clamped her good hand over the wound. “Back door, Blake. You can still make it.”

He looked toward the kitchen, where sunlight lay across the threshold.

Three quiet nights, he thought.

He picked up her rifle instead.

What the Barrels Held

“Maggie,” Jeremiah said, “those barrels beside the front steps. Whiskey?”

“Wash water. Waiting for the carter.”

“Good.”

“You’re pleased about a peculiar thing.”

He pointed to the storeroom’s high window. “Can you reach the barrels from there without being seen?”

“If I keep low.”

“Take a broom.”

Clara watched him pull a tablecloth free and knot it around her arm.

“Explain.”

“Voss has men covering both doors. He’ll come close if he thinks we’re beaten.”

“And are we?” Maggie asked.

Jeremiah pulled the knot tight. Clara’s teeth clicked together.

“Not quite.”

Maggie glanced toward the storeroom, then removed her shoes.

A minute later Jeremiah called into the street.

“Marshal’s hit! I’m coming out. You can have the money.”

“Gun first.”

He slid his revolver across the threshold.

“Both of them,” Voss called.

Jeremiah hesitated, then pushed Clara’s rifle after it. He still had her short-barreled pistol tucked inside his waistband.

Let him count wrong.

He stepped out with his hands raised.

Voss stood beyond the barrels, revolver level. Two men waited near the hitching rail. Another crouched beside the trough.

“Always knew you’d sell anybody,” Voss said.

“You taught a thorough lesson.”

Behind the barrels came a wooden scrape.

Maggie thrust her broom against the barrels, tipping them and dumping dirty wash water over Voss and the man beside him.

Jeremiah dropped flat.

Clara fired a shotgun from the doorway, striking the trough gunman’s shoulder. Jeremiah drew and shot the weapon from Voss’s wet hand. The remaining rider fled before either could turn on him.

Voss crawled toward his fallen revolver.

Maggie stepped beside it in her stocking feet.

“That,” she said, leveling the broom handle at his throat, “is far enough.”

A Different Kind of Engagement

By dawn, Voss and his surviving men were locked in the freight shed under a watch made up mostly of people who had spent the fight beneath furniture.

The doctor stitched Clara’s arm at Maggie’s kitchen table. Jeremiah held the basin. Whenever Clara’s fingers tightened on the table edge, he moved it closer without being asked.

Afterward, Maggie poured three measures of whiskey.

Clara lifted hers with her left hand.

“You saved lives last night.”

Jeremiah watched a fly investigate the bloodied water.

“There’s still that guard.”

“Yes.”

“What was his name?”

“Joseph Tully. Had a wife in Tucson.”

Jeremiah repeated the name quietly.

Maggie set his glass within reach. “Did you keep your share?”

“Some.”

“Enough to matter?”

“To her, maybe.”

Outside, hammers began knocking boards over the saloon windows. Each stroke seemed too loud in the kitchen.

Clara drank. “I can’t escort prisoners until help arrives. Telegraph operator’s sending for deputies. Judge is due through here Saturday.”

“You putting me in the shed?”

She studied him for several seconds.

“Will I need to?”

Jeremiah unbuckled his gun belt and laid it on the table.

“No.”

Jeremiah was not arrested that morning. Clara slept in Maggie’s room with her pistol beneath the pillow. Jeremiah could have reached his mare without passing either woman.

Instead, Maggie found him outside examining the damaged wall.

“Judge might give you years,” she said.

“I expect he might.”

She handed him a scraper.

“Room’s paid through Friday.”

“And after Saturday?”

“Depends what the judge says.” She pressed a second scraper into his hand. “But I’ll keep the work for you.”

Across the street, someone began describing how Jeremiah Blake had faced five guns alone.

He opened his mouth, then looked at Maggie’s cut cheek.

“Marshal faced them,” he called. “Maggie washed them.”

Then he set the spare scraper down and started on the wall.

The End
Clayton Dunne: A Whispered Legend of Justice in Carson's Gulch Read next Clayton Dunne: A Whispered Legend of Justice in Carson's Gulch Clayton Dunne brings justice to Carson's Gulch, facing outlaws with unerring precision. 5 min read →